• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Email
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Top Right Thinking

Asking the right questions

  • About
    • Top Right People
    • The 52 Project
    • Contact Us
  • Dulcie Swanston
    • Coaching with Dulcie
  • Coach Training
    • Our Approach
    • Our Coaching Programmes
    • Testimonials
    • Register Your Interest
    • Login
    • Your Course
  • Consulting
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • How It Works
    • Testimonials
  • Training
    • What We Do
    • How It Works
    • Testimonials
  • Resources
    • Shop
      • Cart
      • Checkout
      • My account
    • Tea Break Coaching
    • Seaside Retreat
    • Resource Hub
    • Imposter Thinking
    • Activities
  • Contact
  • About
    • Top Right People
    • The 52 Project
    • Contact Us
  • Dulcie Swanston
    • Coaching with Dulcie
  • Coach Training
    • Our Approach
    • Our Coaching Programmes
    • Testimonials
    • Register Your Interest
    • Login
    • Your Course
  • Consulting
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • How It Works
    • Testimonials
  • Training
    • What We Do
    • How It Works
    • Testimonials
  • Resources
    • Shop
      • Cart
      • Checkout
      • My account
    • Tea Break Coaching
    • Seaside Retreat
    • Resource Hub
    • Imposter Thinking
    • Activities
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Archives for Training ROI

Training ROI

Why doesn’t training stick ?

September 16, 2016 //  by DulcieTRT//  16 Comments

After years in senior HR roles and managing large teams of people, I was frustrated when we spent time and money on training that didn’t seem to impact on the day job. I would have understood if the training wasn’t very good ! But often this was brilliant training that was delivered by great people, using sound business models and robust research. More often than not, “happy sheets” would provide feedback that the training was great. More often than not almost all the delegates would say that they would definitely use the skills back in the workplace.

So I wanted to do know more about why people who were keen to use the skills back in the workplace, didn’t end up doing so. And what I could do about it.

Cue – lots of research, conversations with training professionals and good old fashioned thinking later…There is one element of the training that I now know from experience can make all the difference. (Clue…it is not the quality of your slides…)

The interest and the involvement of the line manager – before and after the training – makes a significant and measurable difference as to whether training makes a difference to the business. 

It sounds so simple and so obvious. But come on…Let’s be honest. When I was a busy line manager, could I, hand on heart, say that I made proper time to have a powerful conversation with everyone who worked with me, in order make the training investment I had made really count?

No I can’t. And not for bad reasons.

What were my excuses…Err…The main one was that I trusted them to get on with it by themselves. They were capable people. I was sure they would ask if they wanted help…Right?

Well no. Not according to some of the best people I have spoken to who have 100s of years of experience between them. And not according to some of the latest research about what makes us work at work.

Knowledge moving from a classroom to the front line requires the line manager to proactively do something. Trusting people to get on with it sounds like empowerment, but it often doesn’t lead to a new behaviour or a new idea making it into the day to day work life of your teams.

Put simply, the science says your teams will mainly focus their minds on what you talk about and what you “reward” with your attention. 

If you don’t talk to them about what they have just learned and help them to think how they want to use it, 8 weeks later, more than 80% of it will be forgotten. 

“I’d love to do that but I just don’t have the time…” Is a common response I get when I challenge a line manager to do this well. The great news is that I have found a few simple ways to do this that really work.

People who have used it tell me it’s fast and actually quite rewarding.

We use the GROW model as a tool. It’s simple, it works and most people know it. Perhaps we could have invented new acronym, but why bother when this works just great ? We keep it simple.

If you are a line manager and one of your team is going on a training course, give them 4 minutes of your undivided attention and ask them a good “G” question and a good “R” question.

When they get back to work, give then another 4 minutes of your undivided attention and ask them a good “O” and a good “W” question.

Of course, ask more than 1 question if you like. Give them 7 minutes of your undivided attention by all means! However, our research suggests just 2 questions asked before one of your team attends training has a remarkable effect. Promise.

If your mind is blank (or one of your team is meeting you in 2 minutes and you can’t think of a great question…!), then give these a try. You could always build on them to make them more personal.

Pre Training

G (GOAL) Questions:

What are you hoping to get from the training ?

How are you going to measure if attending this training was a success for you (and/or the Company)

What would you love to be saying to me if I called you in the car on the way home after the training?

R (REALITY) Questions:

What is stopping you being really good at this already ? (You may want to probe if this is down to “Skill” or “Will” if you have the time)

What will stop you making the most of this opportunity to learn or practise your skills ?

Are you really up for this? What could change that?
Post Training (ideally within 24 hours but 78 hours max)

O (OPTIONS) Questions:

What things do you want to do differently as a result of the learning ?

What could you start doing differently today?

What could you do and what will you do ? What’s the difference ?

W (WHAT NEXT) Questions:

How will we measure how successful you have been ?

What can I do to help ?

What do you want me to do if you don’t deliver on your good intentions ?

Give it a go. Let us know if it works or how you improve upon it.
And contact us at hello@teabreaktraining.com to find out more about the full Tea Break Training model. We’d love to include your successes in our research…

Category: It's Not Bloody Rocket ScienceTag: Line Manager support, Making training stick, Training ROI, Training waste of money, Training waste of time

70 20 10 and the Learning Curve

April 6, 2016 //  by DulcieTRT//  Leave a Comment

There might be a good reason why £1000s is spent every year on training that people don’t remember and don’t use when they get back to their day job…

I’ve just created a session for a client and had to be pretty challenging. Why? Well because I don’t think we can ignore good science…and so I’m not going to give them the “day in the classroom” they had originally wanted. This is because it is pretty soul destroying for a professional people developer (and value destroying for a business) when your training doesn’t actually change anything back in the business.

A guy called Frank Dempster was equally depressed when he wrote “The Spacing Effect: A Case Study in the Failure to apply the results of Psychological Research” – He was spending his time wondering why on earth everyone was still persisting in teaching everything all at once in a classroom…and then wondering why no one could remember it – rather than spacing out the learning…most expensive business schools for example…

Every bit of research I can find (please do shout if you find a different bit that disproves it !) says that we hardly retain anything that we learn on a training course, unless something happens afterwards. For those of you who know a bit of science Ebbinghaus started in in the 1850s with his forgetting curve and McCall, Lombardo and Eichinger built on it in the 80s and 90s with their 70:20:10 model. I’ve attached the scribbles I did on a flipchart to explain these to this post in case that helps.

I asked for a quick show of hands amongst my contacts. These are great people in brilliant UK and Worldwide businesses. Many say that they are still tasked with running courses that they personally don’t think will change things that much on the ground because not enough time/cost/effort has been put into what will happen with the delegates leave the classroom.

I devised a training programme recently and experimented. I spent 70% of my time and the organisation’s supporting the learning outside the classroom. With amazing results. The classroom element of the training cost £20k. A conservative direct return was delivered of £420k. When I say “conservative”, I excluded any examples of learning that translated into profit that was not absolutely directly attributable or crystal clear. Without those (pretty ruthless) exclusions it seemed to have impacted the business to the tune of more like £4m…What ??!!

So what was different? Firstly, I insisted that every line manager of every delegate attending did what I call a GROW to embed learning with their people. I’ll do another post on this but basically line managers have a discussion before one of their team goes on a course using the G and R of the GROW model and the O and W when the team member gets back to the day job. I also insisted that every delegate had to find a way to practise the skill immediately in their day job. This particular session was about having difficult conversations. I also asked their line managers to discuss the financial implications of having that conversation and to record the direct financial impact. I provided an opportunity to share learning and coach at a later date.

So what sort of things gave that return ? Just a few examples were fraud being uncovered and resolved, sick leave being ended earlier than expected, employees staying rather than leaving and so on

This is why at Tea Break Training we focus on sessions that absolutely minimise the time in the classroom – great news for small businesses in particular because time out is time away from the job getting done in some cases.

We use smart techniques during the training session itself and in the days and weeks following to “top” up the learning several times. This means that the Ebbinghaus curve – which shows how we are wired to forget, rather than to remember – doesn’t happen as often for my clients. If you look at the scribble below that I did for the client showing the curve, the  interventions I inserted into the training are the numbers 1-6 on that Ebbinghaus picture.

We do this through integrating short, sharp coaching into the session, asking delegates to share their learning afterwards, actively encouraging real life practise and insisting on reflection (If you have not read the HBR report on the increase in performance obtained by reflecting and not just doing, please do !)

Let me know if you want to be part of our ongoing and never ending experiment in how to make learning really stick! We are proving every day for clients that those sort of ROI numbers we first experienced weren’t a fluke…and those of you who know me well, or know your science and research, know that I’m not likely to be proved wrong…

Category: TrainingTag: 70 20 10, Ebbinghaus, effective training, forgetting curve, Knowledge retention, learning curve, McCall Lombardo Eichinger, Training ROI, training stickiness, workplace challenges

Footer

Registered Office

Top Right Thinking
34 High Street
Aldridge
Walsall
WS9 8LZ

  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Returns Policy
  • Website Terms & Conditions of Use
Organisational Member: association for coaching

Copyright © 2023 · Top Right Thinking · Site Design by DigitalJen